Advertising

Measure ad effectiveness and optimize campaign performance • 41 papers

8 subtopics

Ad Auctions (GSP, VCG)

Understand how ad bidding and pricing works

Internet Advertising and the Generalized Second-Price Auction Benjamin Edelman, Michael Ostrovsky, Michael Schwarz Analysis of the GSP auction used by Google and the gap from VCG efficiency.
2007 1598 cited

Internet Advertising and the Generalized Second-Price Auction

Benjamin Edelman, Michael Ostrovsky, Michael Schwarz

Analysis of the GSP auction used by Google and the gap from VCG efficiency.

Position Auctions Hal Varian Equilibrium analysis of position auctions with symmetric Nash equilibrium characterization.
2007 745 cited

Position Auctions

Hal Varian

Equilibrium analysis of position auctions with symmetric Nash equilibrium characterization.

Auctions and Bidding: A Guide for Computer Scientists Simon Parsons, Juan Rodriguez-Aguilar, Mark Klein Comprehensive survey of auction theory and mechanism design for practitioners.
2011 2020 cited

Auctions and Bidding: A Guide for Computer Scientists

Simon Parsons, Juan Rodriguez-Aguilar, Mark Klein

Comprehensive survey of auction theory and mechanism design for practitioners.

Counterspeculation, Auctions, and Competitive Sealed Tenders William Vickrey Nobel Prize-winning paper establishing truthful bidding in second-price sealed-bid auctions—the theoretical bedrock for all VCG mechanisms and modern ad auctions. ~8,000 citations.
1961 7222 cited

Counterspeculation, Auctions, and Competitive Sealed Tenders

William Vickrey

Nobel Prize-winning paper establishing truthful bidding in second-price sealed-bid auctions—the theoretical bedrock for all VCG mechanisms and modern ad auctions. ~8,000 citations.

Optimal Auction Design Roger B. Myerson Derives revenue-maximizing auctions and optimal reserve prices via 'virtual value' concept. Essential for understanding how platforms set reserve prices. ~6,400 citations.
1981 5977 cited

Optimal Auction Design

Roger B. Myerson

Derives revenue-maximizing auctions and optimal reserve prices via 'virtual value' concept. Essential for understanding how platforms set reserve prices. ~6,400 citations.

Autobidding & Budget Pacing

Automate campaign bidding and spending

Budget Management Strategies in Repeated Auctions Santiago Balseiro, Vahab Mirrokni, Renato Paes Leme Optimal budget pacing strategies for advertisers in repeated auctions.
2015 25 cited

Budget Management Strategies in Repeated Auctions

Santiago Balseiro, Vahab Mirrokni, Renato Paes Leme

Optimal budget pacing strategies for advertisers in repeated auctions.

Autobidding with Constraints Gagan Aggarwal, Ashwinkumar Badanidiyuru, Aranyak Mehta Value-maximizing autobidding under budget and ROI constraints.
2019 46 cited

Autobidding with Constraints

Gagan Aggarwal, Ashwinkumar Badanidiyuru, Aranyak Mehta

Value-maximizing autobidding under budget and ROI constraints.

From First-Price Auctions to Incentive-Compatible Auctions Yuan Deng, Sébastien Lahaie, Vahab Mirrokni Mechanism design for autobidders and the transition to first-price auctions.
2021

From First-Price Auctions to Incentive-Compatible Auctions

Yuan Deng, Sébastien Lahaie, Vahab Mirrokni

Mechanism design for autobidders and the transition to first-price auctions.

Learning in Repeated Auctions with Budgets: Regret Minimization and Equilibrium Santiago R. Balseiro, Yonatan Gur Introduces adaptive pacing strategies with asymptotic optimality proofs; shows these form approximate Nash equilibrium. The reference paper for budget pacing algorithms at Google/Meta.
2019 27 cited

Learning in Repeated Auctions with Budgets: Regret Minimization and Equilibrium

Santiago R. Balseiro, Yonatan Gur

Introduces adaptive pacing strategies with asymptotic optimality proofs; shows these form approximate Nash equilibrium. The reference paper for budget pacing algorithms at Google/Meta.

Multiplicative Pacing Equilibria in Auction Markets Vincent Conitzer, Christian Kroer, Eric Sodomka, Nicolas Stier-Moses Formalizes pacing equilibrium as game-theoretic solution concept for autobidding; proves existence when platforms use multiplicative bid scaling.
2022 21 cited

Multiplicative Pacing Equilibria in Auction Markets

Vincent Conitzer, Christian Kroer, Eric Sodomka, Nicolas Stier-Moses

Formalizes pacing equilibrium as game-theoretic solution concept for autobidding; proves existence when platforms use multiplicative bid scaling.

Pacing Equilibrium in First Price Auction Markets Vincent Conitzer, Christian Kroer, Debmalya Panigrahi, Okke Schrijvers, Nicolas Stier-Moses, Eric Sodomka, Christopher A. Wilkens Theoretical justification for industry's transition to first-price auctions (Google 2019); proves unique equilibrium and efficient computation via Eisenberg-Gale program.
2022 51 cited

Pacing Equilibrium in First Price Auction Markets

Vincent Conitzer, Christian Kroer, Debmalya Panigrahi, Okke Schrijvers, Nicolas Stier-Moses, Eric Sodomka, Christopher A. Wilkens

Theoretical justification for industry's transition to first-price auctions (Google 2019); proves unique equilibrium and efficient computation via Eisenberg-Gale program.

Attribution & Incrementality

Measure which ads actually caused conversions

Measuring Ad Effectiveness Using Geo Experiments Jon Vaver, Jim Koehler Google's framework for measuring incremental ad impact using geographic experiments.
2011 52 cited

Measuring Ad Effectiveness Using Geo Experiments

Jon Vaver, Jim Koehler

Google's framework for measuring incremental ad impact using geographic experiments.

Ghost Ads: Improving the Economics of Measuring Online Ad Effectiveness Garrett Johnson, Randall Lewis, Elmar Nubbemeyer Novel methodology for measuring ad lift without holdout using predicted ad exposure.
2017 161 cited

Ghost Ads: Improving the Economics of Measuring Online Ad Effectiveness

Garrett Johnson, Randall Lewis, Elmar Nubbemeyer

Novel methodology for measuring ad lift without holdout using predicted ad exposure.

Challenges and Opportunities in Media Mix Modeling Yuxue Jin, Yueqing Wang, Yunting Sun, et al. Google's approach to marketing mix modeling with Bayesian methods.
2017 13 cited

Challenges and Opportunities in Media Mix Modeling

Yuxue Jin, Yueqing Wang, Yunting Sun, et al.

Google's approach to marketing mix modeling with Bayesian methods.

Consumer Heterogeneity and Paid Search Effectiveness: A Large-Scale Field Experiment Thomas Blake, Chris Nosko, Steven Tadelis Landmark eBay experiment showing paid search ROI vastly overestimated—99.5% of brand keyword traffic substitutes to organic. Demonstrates critical importance of experiments over observational methods. ~800 citations.
2015 20 cited

Consumer Heterogeneity and Paid Search Effectiveness: A Large-Scale Field Experiment

Thomas Blake, Chris Nosko, Steven Tadelis

Landmark eBay experiment showing paid search ROI vastly overestimated—99.5% of brand keyword traffic substitutes to organic. Demonstrates critical importance of experiments over observational methods. ~800 citations.

The Unfavorable Economics of Measuring the Returns to Advertising Randall A. Lewis, Justin M. Rao Analyzes 25 large RCTs ($2.8M spend) showing massive sample sizes needed for reliable ad measurement due to individual sales volatility (CV of 10). Explains why selection bias is 'crippling.' ~700 citations.
2015 281 cited

The Unfavorable Economics of Measuring the Returns to Advertising

Randall A. Lewis, Justin M. Rao

Analyzes 25 large RCTs ($2.8M spend) showing massive sample sizes needed for reliable ad measurement due to individual sales volatility (CV of 10). Explains why selection bias is 'crippling.' ~700 citations.

A Comparison of Approaches to Advertising Measurement: Evidence from Big Field Experiments at Facebook Brett R. Gordon, Florian Zettelmeyer, Neha Bhargava, Dan Chapsky Compares RCTs to observational methods using 15 Facebook experiments (1.6B impressions). Demonstrates observational methods consistently fail even with rich behavioral data. ~500 citations.
2019 249 cited

A Comparison of Approaches to Advertising Measurement: Evidence from Big Field Experiments at Facebook

Brett R. Gordon, Florian Zettelmeyer, Neha Bhargava, Dan Chapsky

Compares RCTs to observational methods using 15 Facebook experiments (1.6B impressions). Demonstrates observational methods consistently fail even with rich behavioral data. ~500 citations.

TV Advertising Effectiveness and Profitability: Generalizable Results from 288 Brands Bradley T. Shapiro, Günter J. Hitsch, Anna E. Tuchman Border-strategy identification across 288 brands finds TV ad elasticity of ~0.025—much lower than prior estimates; 80%+ of brands show negative marginal ROI.
2021 135 cited

TV Advertising Effectiveness and Profitability: Generalizable Results from 288 Brands

Bradley T. Shapiro, Günter J. Hitsch, Anna E. Tuchman

Border-strategy identification across 288 brands finds TV ad elasticity of ~0.025—much lower than prior estimates; 80%+ of brands show negative marginal ROI.

Targeting & Lookalikes

Find the right audiences for your ads

A Large Scale Benchmark for Uplift Modeling Eustache Diemert, Artem Betlei, Christophe Renaudin, Massih-Reza Amini Criteo's uplift modeling benchmark and methods for targeting persuadables.
2018 310 cited

A Large Scale Benchmark for Uplift Modeling

Eustache Diemert, Artem Betlei, Christophe Renaudin, Massih-Reza Amini

Criteo's uplift modeling benchmark and methods for targeting persuadables.

Targeting Online Display Ads: Comparing Segment-Based and Individual-Based Targeting Anja Lambrecht, Catherine Tucker Compares effectiveness of behavioral vs. segment-based ad targeting.
2013 254 cited

Targeting Online Display Ads: Comparing Segment-Based and Individual-Based Targeting

Anja Lambrecht, Catherine Tucker

Compares effectiveness of behavioral vs. segment-based ad targeting.

An Experimental Investigation of the Effects of Retargeted Advertising: The Role of Frequency and Timing Navdeep S. Sahni, Sridhar Narayanan, Kirthi Kalyanam Large-scale RCT showing retargeting increases website returns by 14.6%, with effectiveness decaying over time (33% of impact on day 1) and advertising complementarities across weeks.
2019 109 cited

An Experimental Investigation of the Effects of Retargeted Advertising: The Role of Frequency and Timing

Navdeep S. Sahni, Sridhar Narayanan, Kirthi Kalyanam

Large-scale RCT showing retargeting increases website returns by 14.6%, with effectiveness decaying over time (33% of impact on day 1) and advertising complementarities across weeks.

Targeting and Privacy in Mobile Advertising Omid Rafieian, Hema Yoganarasimhan Unified framework combining ML-based targeting with auction models; shows efficient targeting improves CTR by 66.8% over current practice, with implications for privacy regulation.
2021 187 cited

Targeting and Privacy in Mobile Advertising

Omid Rafieian, Hema Yoganarasimhan

Unified framework combining ML-based targeting with auction models; shows efficient targeting improves CTR by 66.8% over current practice, with implications for privacy regulation.

Personalization in Email Marketing: The Role of Noninformative Advertising Content Navdeep S. Sahni, S. Christian Wheeler, Pradeep Chintagunta Field experiments showing adding recipient names increases open rates by 20%, sales leads by 31%—even though names are non-informative. Gary Lilien Prize Finalist.
2018

Personalization in Email Marketing: The Role of Noninformative Advertising Content

Navdeep S. Sahni, S. Christian Wheeler, Pradeep Chintagunta

Field experiments showing adding recipient names increases open rates by 20%, sales leads by 31%—even though names are non-informative. Gary Lilien Prize Finalist.

Brand vs. Performance

Balance short-term sales with long-term brand building

The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing Strategies Les Binet, Peter Field IPA research on optimal balance between brand building and activation.
2013

The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing Strategies

Les Binet, Peter Field

IPA research on optimal balance between brand building and activation.

Online Display Advertising: Targeting and Obtrusiveness Avi Goldfarb, Catherine Tucker Trade-offs between ad targeting precision and user annoyance.
2011 801 cited

Online Display Advertising: Targeting and Obtrusiveness

Avi Goldfarb, Catherine Tucker

Trade-offs between ad targeting precision and user annoyance.

Digital Advertising and Consumer Price Search Xiang Hui, Maryam Saeedi, Zeqian Shen, Neel Sundaresan How digital advertising affects consumer search behavior and market outcomes.
2022 19 cited

Digital Advertising and Consumer Price Search

Xiang Hui, Maryam Saeedi, Zeqian Shen, Neel Sundaresan

How digital advertising affects consumer search behavior and market outcomes.

How Well Does Advertising Work? Generalizations from Meta-Analysis of Brand Advertising Elasticities Raj Sethuraman, Gerard J. Tellis, Richard A. Briesch Definitive meta-analysis of 751 short-term and 402 long-term advertising elasticities from 56 studies (1960-2008). Average short-term elasticity: 0.12; long-term: 0.24. ~440 citations.
2011 452 cited

How Well Does Advertising Work? Generalizations from Meta-Analysis of Brand Advertising Elasticities

Raj Sethuraman, Gerard J. Tellis, Richard A. Briesch

Definitive meta-analysis of 751 short-term and 402 long-term advertising elasticities from 56 studies (1960-2008). Average short-term elasticity: 0.12; long-term: 0.24. ~440 citations.

How TV Advertising Works: A Meta-Analysis of 389 Real World Split Cable TV Advertising Experiments Leonard M. Lodish, Magid Abraham, Stuart Kalmenson, Jeanne Livelsberger, Beth Lubetkin, Bruce Richardson, Mary Ellen Stevens Classic BehaviorScan meta-analysis showing only ~50% of TV ad weight tests had positive sales effects; established that copy/strategy changes matter more than budget increases. Foundational paper.
1995 10 cited

How TV Advertising Works: A Meta-Analysis of 389 Real World Split Cable TV Advertising Experiments

Leonard M. Lodish, Magid Abraham, Stuart Kalmenson, Jeanne Livelsberger, Beth Lubetkin, Bruce Richardson, Mary Ellen Stevens

Classic BehaviorScan meta-analysis showing only ~50% of TV ad weight tests had positive sales effects; established that copy/strategy changes matter more than budget increases. Foundational paper.

Privacy & Ad Effectiveness

Navigate privacy regulations while measuring ads

Privacy Regulation and Online Advertising Avi Goldfarb, Catherine E. Tucker Foundational empirical paper showing EU privacy regulation (ePrivacy Directive) reduced display ad effectiveness by 65% in changing purchase intent. ~2,500 citations.
2011 3 cited

Privacy Regulation and Online Advertising

Avi Goldfarb, Catherine E. Tucker

Foundational empirical paper showing EU privacy regulation (ePrivacy Directive) reduced display ad effectiveness by 65% in changing purchase intent. ~2,500 citations.

The Effect of Privacy Regulation on the Data Industry: Empirical Evidence from GDPR Guy Aridor, Yeon-Koo Che, Tobias Salz Shows GDPR's opt-in led to 12.5% drop in tracked consumers, but remaining consumers are more valuable—demonstrating 'privacy externalities' where privacy-conscious consumers make opt-in consumers more predictable.
2023 119 cited

The Effect of Privacy Regulation on the Data Industry: Empirical Evidence from GDPR

Guy Aridor, Yeon-Koo Che, Tobias Salz

Shows GDPR's opt-in led to 12.5% drop in tracked consumers, but remaining consumers are more valuable—demonstrating 'privacy externalities' where privacy-conscious consumers make opt-in consumers more predictable.

Privacy and Market Concentration: Intended and Unintended Consequences of the GDPR Garrett A. Johnson, Scott K. Shriver, Samuel G. Goldberg Panel data on 27,000+ websites shows GDPR reduced vendor use by 15% but increased market concentration by 17%—large platforms (Google, Facebook) gained share as small vendors dropped.
2023 133 cited

Privacy and Market Concentration: Intended and Unintended Consequences of the GDPR

Garrett A. Johnson, Scott K. Shriver, Samuel G. Goldberg

Panel data on 27,000+ websites shows GDPR reduced vendor use by 15% but increased market concentration by 17%—large platforms (Google, Facebook) gained share as small vendors dropped.

The Economic Consequences of Apple's App Tracking Transparency Guy Aridor, Yeon-Koo Che, Brett Hollenbeck, Daniel McCarthy, Maximilian Kaiser Quantifies ATT's economic effects: 37% reduction in CTR for Meta's conversion-optimized ads; firms with higher Meta dependence experienced 37% revenue decline. Smaller e-commerce firms disproportionately harmed.
2024

The Economic Consequences of Apple's App Tracking Transparency

Guy Aridor, Yeon-Koo Che, Brett Hollenbeck, Daniel McCarthy, Maximilian Kaiser

Quantifies ATT's economic effects: 37% reduction in CTR for Meta's conversion-optimized ads; firms with higher Meta dependence experienced 37% revenue decline. Smaller e-commerce firms disproportionately harmed.

Economic Consequences of Online Tracking Restrictions Klaus M. Miller, Bernd Skiera Studies 128M ad impressions over 2.5 years; average cookie lifetime is 279 days with €2.52 value. One-year cookie restrictions would cost €904M annually in Europe. IJRM Best Article Award 2024.
2024 14 cited

Economic Consequences of Online Tracking Restrictions

Klaus M. Miller, Bernd Skiera

Studies 128M ad impressions over 2.5 years; average cookie lifetime is 279 days with €2.52 value. One-year cookie restrictions would cost €904M annually in Europe. IJRM Best Article Award 2024.

Real-Time Bidding & Programmatic

Buy and sell ads in real-time auctions

Online Display Advertising Markets: A Literature Review and Future Directions Hana Choi, Carl F. Mela, Santiago R. Balseiro, Adam Leary Comprehensive literature review organizing display advertising research by ecosystem agents (advertisers, publishers, intermediaries). Essential reading for understanding the programmatic landscape. ~200 citations.
2020 164 cited

Online Display Advertising Markets: A Literature Review and Future Directions

Hana Choi, Carl F. Mela, Santiago R. Balseiro, Adam Leary

Comprehensive literature review organizing display advertising research by ecosystem agents (advertisers, publishers, intermediaries). Essential reading for understanding the programmatic landscape. ~200 citations.

Repeated Auctions with Budgets in Ad Exchanges: Approximations and Design Santiago R. Balseiro, Omar Besbes, Gabriel Y. Weintraub Introduces Fluid Mean Field Equilibrium (FMFE) framework for budget-constrained advertisers; provides prescriptions for reserve prices and impression allocation. ~500 citations.
2015 18 cited

Repeated Auctions with Budgets in Ad Exchanges: Approximations and Design

Santiago R. Balseiro, Omar Besbes, Gabriel Y. Weintraub

Introduces Fluid Mean Field Equilibrium (FMFE) framework for budget-constrained advertisers; provides prescriptions for reserve prices and impression allocation. ~500 citations.

Real-Time Bidding in Online Display Advertising Amin Sayedi Game-theoretic model showing symmetric advertisers use asymmetric strategies; publishers should maintain reservation contracts alongside RTB for revenue optimization.
2018 91 cited

Real-Time Bidding in Online Display Advertising

Amin Sayedi

Game-theoretic model showing symmetric advertisers use asymmetric strategies; publishers should maintain reservation contracts alongside RTB for revenue optimization.

First-Price Auctions in Online Display Advertising Stylianos Despotakis, R. Ravi, Amin Sayedi Explains industry shift from second-price to first-price auctions as direct economic consequence of header bidding adoption, not trust issues. Analyzes waterfalling vs. header bidding mechanisms.
2021 36 cited

First-Price Auctions in Online Display Advertising

Stylianos Despotakis, R. Ravi, Amin Sayedi

Explains industry shift from second-price to first-price auctions as direct economic consequence of header bidding adoption, not trust issues. Analyzes waterfalling vs. header bidding mechanisms.

Attention & Viewability

Measure whether ads are actually seen

Market Provision of Broadcasting: A Welfare Analysis Simon P. Anderson, Stephen Coate Foundational two-sided market model for advertising-financed media; analyzes when equilibrium advertising levels are socially optimal. The theoretical foundation for attention economics. ~680 citations.
2005 626 cited

Market Provision of Broadcasting: A Welfare Analysis

Simon P. Anderson, Stephen Coate

Foundational two-sided market model for advertising-financed media; analyzes when equilibrium advertising levels are socially optimal. The theoretical foundation for attention economics. ~680 citations.

How Viewer Tuning, Presence, and Attention Respond to Ad Content and Predict Brand Search Lift Matthew McGranaghan, Jura Liaukonyte, Kenneth C. Wilbur First study distinguishing TV ad viewability from actual viewing using passive measurement; finds 30% of TV ads play to empty rooms. Demonstrates attention metrics predict brand search lift better than tuning data.
2022 35 cited

How Viewer Tuning, Presence, and Attention Respond to Ad Content and Predict Brand Search Lift

Matthew McGranaghan, Jura Liaukonyte, Kenneth C. Wilbur

First study distinguishing TV ad viewability from actual viewing using passive measurement; finds 30% of TV ads play to empty rooms. Demonstrates attention metrics predict brand search lift better than tuning data.

Television Advertising and Online Word-of-Mouth: An Empirical Investigation of Social TV Activity Beth L. Fossen, David A. Schweidel Examines 'Social TV'—joint consumption of TV and social media production. TV advertising impacts online WOM volume for both brands and programs. ~200 citations.
2017 85 cited

Television Advertising and Online Word-of-Mouth: An Empirical Investigation of Social TV Activity

Beth L. Fossen, David A. Schweidel

Examines 'Social TV'—joint consumption of TV and social media production. TV advertising impacts online WOM volume for both brands and programs. ~200 citations.

Sponsorship Disclosure and Consumer Deception: Experimental Evidence from Native Advertising Navdeep S. Sahni, Harikesh S. Nair Field experiments on how native advertising disclosure affects consumer behavior; provides causal evidence on tension between ad effectiveness and consumer deception in native formats.
2020 62 cited

Sponsorship Disclosure and Consumer Deception: Experimental Evidence from Native Advertising

Navdeep S. Sahni, Harikesh S. Nair

Field experiments on how native advertising disclosure affects consumer behavior; provides causal evidence on tension between ad effectiveness and consumer deception in native formats.

Must-read papers for tech economists and applied researchers