Sports Economics & Analytics

Value players and predict outcomes in professional sports • 16 papers

4 subtopics

Player Labor Markets & Team Economics

Analyze player compensation, free agency, revenue sharing, and competitive balance in sports leagues

The Baseball Players' Labor Market Simon Rottenberg THE birth certificate of sports economics. Introduced the Invariance Principle (predating Coase's Theorem) showing talent allocation would be identical under free agency or the reserve clause. Also articulated the Uncertainty of Outcome Hypothesis: competitive balance matters for fan interest.
1956 1342 cited

The Baseball Players' Labor Market

Simon Rottenberg

THE birth certificate of sports economics. Introduced the Invariance Principle (predating Coase's Theorem) showing talent allocation would be identical under free agency or the reserve clause. Also articulated the Uncertainty of Outcome Hypothesis: competitive balance matters for fan interest.

Pay and Performance in Major League Baseball Gerald W. Scully Pioneered empirical estimation of player marginal revenue product (MRP). Using two-stage regression (performance→wins→revenue), demonstrated players earned just 10-20% of their MRP under the reserve clause—empirical ammunition for free agency litigation.
1974 652 cited

Pay and Performance in Major League Baseball

Gerald W. Scully

Pioneered empirical estimation of player marginal revenue product (MRP). Using two-stage regression (performance→wins→revenue), demonstrated players earned just 10-20% of their MRP under the reserve clause—empirical ammunition for free agency litigation.

Cross-Subsidization, Incentives, and Outcomes in Professional Team Sports Leagues Rodney Fort, James Quirk Synthesized 40 years of sports economics research into the definitive framework. Striking finding: revenue sharing generally has no impact on competitive balance (reinforcing Rottenberg's invariance), though salary caps do affect balance.
1995 661 cited

Cross-Subsidization, Incentives, and Outcomes in Professional Team Sports Leagues

Rodney Fort, James Quirk

Synthesized 40 years of sports economics research into the definitive framework. Striking finding: revenue sharing generally has no impact on competitive balance (reinforcing Rottenberg's invariance), though salary caps do affect balance.

The Loser's Curse: Decision Making and Market Efficiency in the National Football League Draft Cade Massey, Richard H. Thaler Demonstrated NFL draft picks are systematically overvalued. Top picks generate less surplus value than late first-rounders, teams exhibit overconfidence and the winner's curse. Implied discount rate in multi-year trades reached 136%. Influenced teams like New England to trade down systematically.
2013 158 cited

The Loser's Curse: Decision Making and Market Efficiency in the National Football League Draft

Cade Massey, Richard H. Thaler

Demonstrated NFL draft picks are systematically overvalued. Top picks generate less surplus value than late first-rounders, teams exhibit overconfidence and the winner's curse. Implied discount rate in multi-year trades reached 136%. Influenced teams like New England to trade down systematically.

Game Theory & Strategic Behavior in Sports

Test equilibrium predictions and strategic decision-making using sports as natural experiments

Professionals Play Minimax Ignacio Palacios-Huerta Analyzed 1,417 penalty kicks from top European leagues. Kickers and goalkeepers play exactly according to mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium: success probabilities are statistically identical across strategies, and choices show true serial independence. First field support for both implications of von Neumann's Minimax Theorem.
2003 332 cited

Professionals Play Minimax

Ignacio Palacios-Huerta

Analyzed 1,417 penalty kicks from top European leagues. Kickers and goalkeepers play exactly according to mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium: success probabilities are statistically identical across strategies, and choices show true serial independence. First field support for both implications of von Neumann's Minimax Theorem.

Minimax Play at Wimbledon Mark Walker, John Wooders Confirmed equilibrium behavior in tennis serves using championship matches featuring McEnroe, Borg, Becker, and Sampras. The same statistical tests that soundly reject equilibrium play in experimental data confirm equilibrium behavior among elite professionals.
2001 392 cited

Minimax Play at Wimbledon

Mark Walker, John Wooders

Confirmed equilibrium behavior in tennis serves using championship matches featuring McEnroe, Borg, Becker, and Sampras. The same statistical tests that soundly reject equilibrium play in experimental data confirm equilibrium behavior among elite professionals.

Expertise, Gender, and Equilibrium Play Romain Gauriot, Lionel Page, John Wooders Extended minimax analysis to nearly 500,000 serves across 3,000 matches. Found higher-ranked players conform more closely to equilibrium theory, and substantial differences in degree to which men and women conform to equilibrium predictions.
2023 12 cited

Expertise, Gender, and Equilibrium Play

Romain Gauriot, Lionel Page, John Wooders

Extended minimax analysis to nearly 500,000 serves across 3,000 matches. Found higher-ranked players conform more closely to equilibrium theory, and substantial differences in degree to which men and women conform to equilibrium predictions.

Professionals Do Not Play Minimax: Evidence from Major League Baseball and the National Football League Kenneth Kovash, Steven D. Levitt Found minimax violations in baseball pitch selection and football play-calling. Pitchers throw too many fastballs; football teams pass less than they should. Suggests the strategic simplicity of penalty kicks and tennis serves may be key to equilibrium play.
2009 14 cited

Professionals Do Not Play Minimax: Evidence from Major League Baseball and the National Football League

Kenneth Kovash, Steven D. Levitt

Found minimax violations in baseball pitch selection and football play-calling. Pitchers throw too many fastballs; football teams pass less than they should. Suggests the strategic simplicity of penalty kicks and tennis serves may be key to equilibrium play.

Sports Betting & Prediction Markets

Study market efficiency, biases, and information aggregation in betting markets

Anomalies: Parimutuel Betting Markets: Racetracks and Lotteries Richard H. Thaler, William T. Ziemba Established betting markets as legitimate venues for testing rationality. Despite quick feedback that should facilitate learning, the favorite-longshot bias persists—bettors systematically overweight longshots.
1988 618 cited

Anomalies: Parimutuel Betting Markets: Racetracks and Lotteries

Richard H. Thaler, William T. Ziemba

Established betting markets as legitimate venues for testing rationality. Despite quick feedback that should facilitate learning, the favorite-longshot bias persists—bettors systematically overweight longshots.

Explaining the Favorite-Longshot Bias: Is it Risk-Love or Misperceptions? Erik Snowberg, Justin Wolfers Used 5.6 million horse race starts and exotic bet pricing to discriminate between competing theories. Evidence favors probability misperceptions (prospect theory) over risk-love: longshots return about -61% while favorites return approximately -5%.
2010 85 cited

Explaining the Favorite-Longshot Bias: Is it Risk-Love or Misperceptions?

Erik Snowberg, Justin Wolfers

Used 5.6 million horse race starts and exotic bet pricing to discriminate between competing theories. Evidence favors probability misperceptions (prospect theory) over risk-love: longshots return about -61% while favorites return approximately -5%.

Why Are Gambling Markets Organised So Differently from Financial Markets? Steven D. Levitt Explains why bookmakers set prices rather than equilibrating supply and demand. Bookmakers are more skilled at predicting outcomes than bettors and systematically exploit bettor biases by choosing prices that deviate from market clearing.
2004 369 cited

Why Are Gambling Markets Organised So Differently from Financial Markets?

Steven D. Levitt

Explains why bookmakers set prices rather than equilibrating supply and demand. Bookmakers are more skilled at predicting outcomes than bettors and systematically exploit bettor biases by choosing prices that deviate from market clearing.

Sports Analytics Methods

Apply statistical and machine learning methods to player evaluation and game strategy

An Economic Model of a Professional Sports League Mohamed El-Hodiri, James Quirk First mathematically rigorous league model. Key finding: equalization of playing strengths is inconsistent with profit maximization under standard rules—challenged assumptions about natural competitive balance.
1971 535 cited

An Economic Model of a Professional Sports League

Mohamed El-Hodiri, James Quirk

First mathematically rigorous league model. Key finding: equalization of playing strengths is inconsistent with profit maximization under standard rules—challenged assumptions about natural competitive balance.

Rank-Order Tournaments as Optimum Labor Contracts Edward P. Lazear, Sherwin Rosen Provides the theoretical foundation for understanding prize structures in sports. Key predictions: effort increases with the spread between winning and losing prizes, and only the difference matters, not absolute prize sizes. Introduced competitive handicapping for efficient competition among heterogeneous abilities.
1981 4453 cited

Rank-Order Tournaments as Optimum Labor Contracts

Edward P. Lazear, Sherwin Rosen

Provides the theoretical foundation for understanding prize structures in sports. Key predictions: effort increases with the spread between winning and losing prizes, and only the difference matters, not absolute prize sizes. Introduced competitive handicapping for efficient competition among heterogeneous abilities.

The Economic Design of Sporting Contests Stefan Szymanski Comprehensive review covering optimal prize structures, incentive-balance tradeoffs, and revenue sharing effects. Draws together research on individualistic sports (golf, footraces) with team sports (baseball, soccer) through the lens of contest theory.
2003 184 cited

The Economic Design of Sporting Contests

Stefan Szymanski

Comprehensive review covering optimal prize structures, incentive-balance tradeoffs, and revenue sharing effects. Draws together research on individualistic sports (golf, footraces) with team sports (baseball, soccer) through the lens of contest theory.

Do Firms Maximize? Evidence from Professional Football David Romer Used dynamic programming to show NFL teams punt and kick field goals far too often. Going for a touchdown from the opponent's 2-yard line instead of taking the field goal increases win probability by approximately 3%. Originally titled 'It's Fourth Down and What Does the Bellman Equation Say?'
2006 214 cited

Do Firms Maximize? Evidence from Professional Football

David Romer

Used dynamic programming to show NFL teams punt and kick field goals far too often. Going for a touchdown from the opponent's 2-yard line instead of taking the field goal increases win probability by approximately 3%. Originally titled 'It's Fourth Down and What Does the Bellman Equation Say?'

A Multiresolution Stochastic Process Model for Predicting Basketball Possession Outcomes Daniel Cervone, Alexander D'Amour, Luke Bornn, Kirk Goldsberry Introduced Expected Possession Value (EPV) using player tracking data—the foundation for real-time decision valuation in basketball. Models possessions at multiple resolution levels, differentiating continuous player movements from discrete events like shots and turnovers.
2016 121 cited

A Multiresolution Stochastic Process Model for Predicting Basketball Possession Outcomes

Daniel Cervone, Alexander D'Amour, Luke Bornn, Kirk Goldsberry

Introduced Expected Possession Value (EPV) using player tracking data—the foundation for real-time decision valuation in basketball. Models possessions at multiple resolution levels, differentiating continuous player movements from discrete events like shots and turnovers.

Must-read papers for tech economists and applied researchers